Aston Villa receive email from Premier League over transfer concerns

Crystal Pix/MB Media/GettyImages

The Premier League has issued a stern warning to its 20 member clubs about the consequences of engaging in fraudulent player transfers during the summer window according to The Telegraph. This comes amid scrutiny of recent player-swap deals, which have raised concerns about compliance with financial regulations.

With the Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) deadline on June 30th, clubs are rushing to finalise their accounts. The financial year-end has led to a surge in transfer activity as clubs aim to avoid breaching the PSR, which limits losses to £105 million over a rolling three-year period. Last season, Everton and Nottingham Forest faced penalties for violating these rules, prompting increased vigilance this year.

Aston Villa has been particularly active in the transfer market. The club has sanctioned the sale of Tim Iroegbunam to Everton for £9 million, while Lewis Dobbin has moved in the opposite direction for a reported £10 million.

Additionally, Chelsea is set to acquire Villa midfielder Omari Kellyman for £19 million, with Villa welcoming Ian Maatsen from Stamford Bridge in a deal worth an initial £37.5 million.

The Premier League's legal team has expressed concerns about whether these recent deals represent "good faith arm's length transactions over £1 million." The league has the authority to demand detailed information on transfer negotiations, including internal and external correspondence and any other relevant documentation. This scrutiny aims to ensure that transactions are conducted fairly and transparently.

If the Premier League determines that a transfer was not conducted at arm's length, it can impose fair market value (FMV) rules. These rules are designed to prevent the false inflation of commercial deals and ensure that transactions reflect accurate prices.

The FMV rules consider various factors, including a player's age, position, playing statistics, honours, and injury history, as well as the financial state and bargaining position of the clubs involved.

In March, Aston Villa disclosed a substantial operating loss of approximately £119.6 million for the 2022-23 season. However, the club's revenue saw a significant rise, reaching £217.7 million compared to £178.4 million the previous year. This increase was attributed to better league standings, higher gate receipts, and boosted sponsorship and commercial revenues. The club stressed that these financial results are in line with their strategic business plan and affirmed their continued compliance with the Premier League's PSR.

Jamie Herbert, the Premier League's director of governance, has emphasised to clubs their duty to conduct all transactions with the "utmost good faith." According to Section B.15 of the Premier League's transfer regulations, any form of dishonest behaviour towards the league or other clubs, as well as efforts to bypass these rules or hinder investigations, is strictly forbidden.

Herbert's email also highlighted that clubs might be required to refund transfer fees, either partially or in full, if any fee is found to be inflated. The rule states,

"For the avoidance of doubt and by way of example only, it shall be a breach of the duties under this rule to act dishonestly towards the league or another club; or engage in conduct that is intended to circumvent these rules or obstruct the board's investigation of compliance with them."

The Premier League's recent warning serves as a reminder of the potential consequences of fraudulent transfer activities. While there is no suggestion that any clubs, including Aston Villa, have breached the rules, the league's vigilance underscores the importance of transparency and integrity in the transfer market.