Will Unai Emery start the super-sub or stick with the struggling superstar?

Aston Villa are currently navigating a striking conundrum as the 2024/25 Premier League season unfolds. The team are caught between the underwhelming performances of star forward Ollie Watkins and the promising displays of young Colombian talent Jhon Duran. This unexpected dilemma has sparked a lively debate among fans and pundits alike about who should spearhead Unai Emery's attack.

Watkins' goal drought raises concerns

Ollie Watkins, who was Aston Villa's top scorer last season, has found himself in a rut at the start of this campaign. The 28-year-old England international has failed to score in his first three league appearances, extending his goalless streak to eight matches. This dry spell matches his longest barren run since before Emery took charge at Villa Park.

Watkins' struggles are particularly noticeable in his conversion rate. He currently leads the league in big chances missed, having squandered four clear-cut opportunities in just three games. This lack of finishing prowess has not gone unnoticed by fans and analysts.

Daniel Storey, a journalist for the i newsletter, suggests that Watkins' form might be suffering due to the aftereffects of a demanding summer, during which he was part of England's Euro 2024 squad. Storey notes that Watkins is currently "the Premier League player underperforming his expected goals figure most emphatically."

Duran's super-sub heroics

In stark contrast, Jhon Duran has been a breath of fresh air for Villa. The 20-year-old has made a significant impact off the bench, scoring two match-winning goals in his three substitute appearances this season. His contributions have already secured four valuable points for the club, a tally only surpassed by Manchester City's Erling Haaland.

Duran's efficiency in front of goal is remarkable. Among players with five or more Premier League goals, only Haaland has a better minutes-per-goal rate than Duran's impressive 96 minutes. This knack for scoring crucial goals as a substitute has drawn comparisons to some of the league's most prolific scorers.

Emery's selection headache

As Villa prepare for upcoming matches against Everton and Wolves, manager Unai Emery faces a challenging decision. While Watkins' history suggests he will eventually regain his scoring touch, Duran's impact cannot be ignored. The idea of starting Duran over Watkins is gaining traction among supporters.

Villa captain John McGinn has lauded Duran's recent performances and attitude, saying, "He has all the attributes to be a world-class striker, and we're seeing glimpses of it now." McGinn also expressed confidence in Watkins' ability to rebound, acknowledging that players returning from summer tournaments often need time to find their rhythm.

The road ahead

Emery's handling of this striking dilemma will be closely watched. Will he continue to rely on Watkins' proven ability, or will Duran's impressive performances earn him a starting role?

Despite the current situation, there is a sense of optimism within the Villa camp. With favourable fixtures on the horizon, both strikers will have opportunities to stake their claim for a starting spot. As the competition heats up, Villans can anticipate an exciting battle for the striker position in the weeks to come.