Premier League clubs vote down Aston Villa, agree on new financial system

Crystal Pix/MB Media/GettyImages

The Premier League is gearing up for a significant change in its financial landscape as clubs unanimously agreed to trial a new financial system for the 2024/25 season during their recent Annual General Meeting.

This decision aims to promote financial sustainability and maintain a level playing field among the league's clubs while ensuring alignment with UEFA's new financial regulations.

The trial period, which will be implemented on a non-binding basis, will provide the league and its clubs with an opportunity to assess the effectiveness of the new system and engage in comprehensive consultations with all stakeholders involved.

The existing Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR) will remain in place during this period, but clubs will also be required to adhere to Squad Cost Rules (SCR) and Top to Bottom Anchoring (TBA) on a shadow basis.

Under the SCR, clubs must restrict their on-pitch expenditures to a designated percentage (85 percent) of their football revenue and net profit/loss from player sales. Meanwhile, TBA will function as a league-wide benchmark linked to football expenses, determined by multiplying the projected lowest central distribution for the season

The Premier League is confident that this trial period will provide valuable insights into the implications of the new financial system, enabling them to make any necessary adjustments before its full implementation.

The overarching goal of the system is to foster aspiration among clubs, enhance their competitiveness in UEFA club competitions, and ensure transparency and clarity for all parties involved.

Aston Villa's attempt to increase the allowed Profit and Sustainability (PSR) losses by £30m was met with resistance from their Premier League rivals. The proposal garnered support from only two clubs, while 15 voted against it, and three abstained from voting.

Under the current regulations, Premier League clubs are permitted to incur a maximum loss of £105m over a three-year period. Aston Villa is believed to be approaching this limit, which could have significant implications for the club.

Manager Unai Emery may be forced to part ways with key player Douglas Luiz, who has attracted strong interest from Italian giants Juventus.

Although Villa experienced losses of almost £120 million in 2023, which UEFA asserts are the highest in Europe, the club insists that these figures align with V Sports' strategic business plan.

The Premier League's new spending cap rules, scheduled to replace PSR starting in the 2025/26 season, have sparked considerable debate this season. Everton and Nottingham Forest have already incurred points deductions under these new regulations, which allow clubs not involved in European competitions to allocate up to 85 percent of their revenue to squad expenses. Conversely, clubs participating in European competitions will be limited to spending a maximum of 70 percent, in line with UEFA guidelines.

It remains to be seen how clubs will navigate the new financial landscape and the impact it will have on the future of English football. The 2024/25 trial period will serve as a crucial testing ground for the effectiveness of these measures and their influence on the league's competitiveness and long-term sustainability.