Aston Villa's shrewd move that left Celtic to wonder what could have been

In 2018, Aston Villa pulled off a coup by signing John McGinn from Hibernian, beating Celtic to the punch. The Scottish midfielder's move to Villa Park marked a turning point for both the player and the club, one that has yielded rich dividends.

McGinn, a lifelong Celtic fan with family ties to the club, seemed destined for Parkhead. However, Celtic's hesitation over meeting Hibernian's £3.5 million asking price opened the door for Aston Villa to swoop in with a competitive offer. Paul McGinn, John's brother and a fellow professional footballer, expressed surprise at Celtic's reluctance. Paul told Open Goal (YouTube),

"You wouldn't have imagined [his rise to the top. I remember watching the games against Celtic and thinking 'surely they are going to take him as a no-risk signing'. He has done really well against them. This is a no risk. Down south with Aston Villa, they were still in the Championship at the time. I think they were mid-table, but they made a right few good signings."

At the time of McGinn's signing, Aston Villa was navigating financial difficulties. New owners Nassef Sawiris and Wes Edens had just taken over, aiming to revitalise the club. McGinn became their first significant signing in this new era, secured for around £3 million—a move now seen as one of football's great bargains. Despite being in the Championship and mid-table, Villa recognised McGinn's potential and took a calculated risk that has paid off handsomely.

McGinn's impact at Villa and beyond

John McGinn's impact at Aston Villa has been profound. His leadership qualities were evident, leading Steven Gerrard to appoint him as captain during his tenure. Last season, McGinn played 53 times for Villa, contributing significantly with nine goals and seven assists.

His performances have also shone on the international stage, representing Scotland at Euro 2024 in Germany and further highlighting his abilities as a top-tier midfielder.

Currently sidelined with an injury, McGinn is expected to return in time for Aston Villa's Champions League clash against Celtic—a match laden with personal significance given his history with both clubs.

Reflecting on his brother's journey, Paul McGinn admitted he never anticipated John's rise to such prominence. "To be at the top of your game for that long is unbelievable. It's so tough," Paul said. "You never had seen it [McGinn's rise]. I thought he might have played in the Premier League, but been a bit-part."

Celtic's hesitation allowed Aston Villa to make a strategic acquisition that continues to benefit them significantly. For John McGinn, it was a chance to shine on a larger stage. One he has embraced fully.