Skip to main content

Aston Villa signings ranked: Nicolas Jackson rises, Alejandro Garnacho struggles

How are Villa's new signings progressing at the international break?
ByMark Oldacres
Nicolas Jackson is on a goalscoring hot streak.
Nicolas Jackson is on a goalscoring hot streak. | Michael Regan/GettyImages

Another international break provides another moment to take stock of Aston Villa’s new signings and evaluate their progress so far.

Villa have played nine games across three competitions since the last break, providing plenty of opportunities for players to improve their standing within the squad. While some have climbed the ranks, others have been through rougher patches of form.

Here is an updated ranking of Villa’s ten summer signings based on their contributions to the team so far:

10. Alejandro Garnacho (no change)

Garnacho is still on the outside looking in at Villa since his summer loan move from Chelsea. He has not started a single game for the club so far and was left out of the matchday squad for the last match against Manchester United.

There has not been any more clarification on the trigger point to turn his loan into a permanent signing via a conditional obligation, but right now Garnacho seems no closer to breaking into Unai Emery’s first team.

9. Taylor Harwood-Bellis (-1)

Harwood-Bellis made his first Premier League start for Villa last weekend, albeit it was away from his natural position as he filled in at right-back with no senior options available.

He acquitted himself well considering the circumstances and has done himself no harm whenever he has got the chance to play, with his two other starts coming in the Carabao Cup. He still faces a battle to get regular minutes though with Victor Lindelof locked in at centre-back.

8. Matteo Ruggeri (-1)

Ruggeri has been out of sight, out of mind after suffering a hamstring injury against Brentford which is still keeping him out. He indicated he is close to returning on his Instagram account recently, and has looked solid in his limited playing time so far.

7. Leon Goretzka (+2)

It was a long wait for Villa fans to finally see Goretzka in claret and blue, but the experienced midfielder is finally seeing the field, starting three of Villa’s last four games before the break and netting his first goal for the club against Man United in the 4-4 draw.

Whether he or Joao Gomes are fitting replacements for Youri Tielemans is still up for debate, but Goretzka is starting to show what he could bring to the team.

6. Aaron Wan-Bissaka (no change)

Another injury victim, Wan-Bissaka has been out with a hamstring since pulling up in the Newcastle victory last month, but could be available again after the international break.

He did an admirable job filling in on his unnatural side at left-back and looked to be getting more comfortable before the injury.

5. Joao Gomes (-1)

Gomes is a difficult player to analyse right now. He has had bright moments, playing well against Newcastle, Viking and Manchester City, but there have been lows as well, most prominently his early error which gifted Barcelona the lead in a recent Champions League game.

As things stand, Gomes looks a bit of an odd fit in Emery’s system, and may be starting to fall behind Goretzka in the pecking order. The next few games will be telling in that regard.

4. Ibrahim Mbaye (+1)

Villa fans have not seen as much of Mbaye in recent matches, but his quality was on full display in Champions League victories over Fenerbahce and Viking, and he also provided an assist against Manchester City off the bench, setting up Nicolas Jackson for the winning goal.

Mbaye is being kept out of the team by Alysson at the moment, but should become more of a factor as the season goes on.

3. Zion Suzuki (-2)

Suzuki won the top spot in these rankings at the last international break, and the goalkeeper continued his strong form against Manchester City and for most of the match against Fulham.

Then he dropped Alex Iwobi’s corner over the goal line to undo his many excellent saves, and was also at fault for Man United’s last-minute equaliser, failing to claim a corner.

Suzuki has still been a success overall and there is nothing to worry about. Every ‘keeper makes mistakes, but those mistakes drop him down the rankings slightly when other players have been on top form.

2. Johan Manzambi (+1)

Manzambi gave Villa fans a taste of his ability in the 3-2 win at Spurs right before the last break, and has gone from strength to strength since then, providing goals and assists regularly and proving himself to be a crucial part of Emery’s side.

1. Nicolas Jackson (+1)

Jackson is becoming a talismanic figure up front for Villa, delivering with goals on a weekly basis, scoring six in his last six Premier League games and eight in his last nine including the Champions League.

He was deservedly named Premier League Player of the Month for October, making history as the first Villa player to do so in over ten years. Jackson has been everything they could have hoped for so far.

Add us as a preferred source on Google