In any team, there are players whose performance makes a bigger difference than others to their team’s results. Aston Villa are no different, and after so many key players left in the summer, fans are still learning who the swing players are in Unai Emery’s team.
By looking at WhoScored’s match ratings, we can get an early indication as to which players key to whether Villa win or not.
For the sake of this exercise, only players with more than five appearances in which they have either played at least 45 minutes or contributed a goal or an assist off the bench will be considered.
It goes without saying that in general, most players get better match ratings in a win than when they lose or draw. Compared to their average match rating this season, Villa’s squad has been around 13% better when they win compared to when they don’t.
What we’re looking for then is the players who exceed those numbers one way or another. The players who had the largest influence on wins and non-wins, as well as the ones who maintain their levels even when the team is not victorious.
So far this season, the four players with the biggest differential in their match rating when Villa win compared to when they don’t are in order: Ross Barkley, Joao Gomes, Emi Buendia and Pau Torres.
Barkley’s match rating in wins has been 8.32 on average, compared to 6.43 in draws or losses. It is partially influenced by a 6.15 rating when he had to play as a striker in Villa’s opening day hammering at Brighton, but also a dreadful 5.97 rating in the loss to Nottingham Forest.
On the flipside, he played a big part in wins over Coventry in the Carabao Cup and Champions League victories over Fenerbahce and Viking, earning excellent match ratings in those three games.
Seeing Gomes and Buendia on this list is not a surprise, as their performances can be very volatile game to game.
The fact three midfield players who have been in and out of the team are at the top of the list sums up the problems Emery is having as he looks for the right balance in the middle of the park next to Boubacar Kamara, with Leon Goretzka now part of that competition as well.
Torres has always been a vital player for Emery since signing due to his ability to help Villa build out from the back.
That was best shown in the Champions League win away at Brugge, but there have been some disappointing performances from him this season, including the opening day against Brighton and the recent 3-0 loss to Barcelona. Villa need Torres at his best if they are to start clicking.
On the other end of the spectrum, the three players that stand out as performing almost equally well regardless of whether Villa win are Alysson, Ian Maatsen and Aaron Wan-Bissaka.
Alysson’s average match rating is nearly identical (7.14 to 7.13) when Villa win compared to when they don’t, while Maatsen and Wan-Bissaka are only slightly better (6.47 to 6.41 and 6.85 to 6.77 respectively).
This speaks to why Alysson has become a trusted part of Emery’s first-team picture in recent weeks.
He has already gained a level of consistency which will appeal to the manager, and he is going to be difficult to force out of the starting 11 at the moment, even with exciting players like Ibrahim Mbaye waiting in the wings.
Maatsen was just handed a new contract to reflect his status as Villa’s top left-back, and his ability to handle tough assignments in terms of opposing wingers has been impressive, including a resolute performance against Lamine Yamal.
Interestingly, no Villa player has a better win percentage than Wan-Bissaka, who has won five of the seven matches where he has played at least 45 minutes. The only other player with a win rate better than 50% is Alysson, who has won four of seven.
It is important to note that any players who were not involved in the first two league games of the season, when Villa were a disaster, is going to have an inherent advantage over those who were unfortunate enough to play in those matches while the squad was still being put together.
The data will likely change throughout the season, so it will be interesting to track who Villa’s most important players are by the end of the campaign.
